Most people who’ve spent real time in the music business already know artist management might be the worst job in it. You find an artist before anyone cares, you spend years building the team, the plan and the deals, and the moment it finally starts paying off is often the moment the relationship ends.
It keeps happening at the top of the business too. Dua Lipa left TaP Management in 2022 after eight years with the team that built her, and Chappell Roan parted ways with her management team in November 2024, right as her career exploded. We don’t know what happened behind the scenes in either case, and we’re not taking sides. The pattern is what matters here, because it says a lot about how manager deals are set up.
How do artist managers get paid?
Most managers take a commission, usually somewhere between 15 and 20% of what the artist earns. When the relationship ends, a sunset clause typically pays the manager a shrinking cut of the deals they made during the term for a set number of years, and then it goes to zero.
That means a manager can spend five years building an artist from nothing and walk away owning none of it. They don’t own the songs, they don’t own the masters and they don’t own a piece of the business they helped create. The artist keeps every asset, which is how it should work when the manager came in late, but it’s a rough trade when the manager was the one who took the early risk.
Why would good managers keep taking that risk?
This is the question I keep coming back to. If the big win usually ends in a split, why would an experienced manager keep betting years of their life on new artists without owning anything?
A good manager is a working professional with a family, bills and other opportunities, and they’re going to spend their time where they can build something that lasts. The more the business keeps running this way, the fewer competent managers you’ll see willing to develop artists from zero, and the more of that work falls on young managers who are still learning on the job.
It also takes longer to break an artist now, usually more than three years, so a talented manager who’s been burned before isn’t going to keep signing three-year deals with a sunset clause. That’s why so many end up signing their artists to label or publishing deals, or they quit management altogether.
That’s why some managers ask for a piece
Plenty of experienced managers already work around this. Some start their own label or publishing company and sign the artists they manage. Others set up a shared company with the artist that co-owns the songs and masters made while they’re working together.
Dua Lipa’s story is the clearest public example. Her management company, TaP, also ran the publishing company that owned her song catalog. When she left TaP management in 2022, the commission stopped but that ownership didn’t, and a year later she bought her publishing rights back from them. The terms were never made public, but TaP walked away holding a real asset because they owned a piece of what they helped build.
Lawyers will push back on this, and they have a point. When a manager also owns part of the artist’s publishing or masters, they’re sitting on both sides of the table, so any arrangement like this has to be spelled out clearly upfront with separate representation for the artist.
Why not just sign the artist to a label or publishing deal?
People on the business side usually say exactly that, and it’s a fair question. But if I’m the artist, I want the person who believed in me first to have skin in the game as my manager, not as my label or publishing partner.
Owning those assets lets a manager keep one foot out the door, because if the relationship ends they still hold the rights, often for a long time. That gives them less reason to keep steering the ship the way a manager should, and a label or publishing deal can keep taking your new songs for years after you’ve split.
Find artists early enough to build with them.
Before The Data tracks unsigned artists while the story is still taking shape, so you can get in before the market does.
Our take: it’s a conveyor belt
I don’t think there’s a clean fix. The standard deal puts managers and artists at odds over time, so the splits keep coming and a new manager steps in to start the cycle again.
The music business is one of the only businesses where someone can help build a company from day one and not be entitled to any equity, and I think that conversation needs to change.
There is a caveat, and it matters. It depends on when the manager showed up. I’ve managed artists myself, and if you built an artist from zero, I think a piece of ownership is fair. If you came in after the artist already broke on their own, you shouldn’t own anything, because you didn’t take that risk.
Do you still need a manager?
Yes. Some artists will tell you they don’t, and early on you can run a lot of it yourself, but once you want to scale someone has to run the team, the deals and the plan while you focus on the music. There’s no real way around that.
The better question is what kind of deal you’re signing, and whether it rewards the person who’s going to take the most risk on you.
What young managers should do
Not every artist or story is the same, but if you’re a young manager who finds an artist early and actually does the work, set up ownership at the start instead of hoping to sort it out after the split. There are a few ways to do it:
- A publishing joint venture with the artist on the songs written during your term.
- A label joint venture or a production deal on the recordings you help fund and develop.
- A shared company that owns everything made during the management term.
Set it up like a startup
The shared company is the cleanest version, and it’s how I’d do it. You form an LLC with the artist, the songs and masters made during the management term go into it, and an operating agreement sets the split between you. You can even add a vesting schedule, so the manager doesn’t own the songs or control the rights. They own equity in the LLC and a share of its revenue, and that stake only grows while they’re still doing the job.
If you part ways, the manager keeps their share of what you built together but gets nothing new after that, and the artist starts fresh and keeps putting out music. The incentive is to stay, which is the whole point, and the relationship gets treated like a startup with real partners instead of a traditional management deal where the manager creates value in the business but never keeps any of it.
This is for the great managers
There are clearly bad managers out there, and you should never partner with them this way. This is for the great ones who want to spend the next 10 years building an artist’s career from zero, before there’s even a business, and it only covers the manager and the artist, so nobody else gets a bigger piece.
A lot of artists pushed back when I first asked whether management is the worst job in music, and I get it. Not every manager is great, but there are plenty of bad artists too, and if you’ve never developed an artist from zero, spent years of your own time and then watched them walk, it’s hard to see the other side. The artist needs the manager and the manager needs the artist if they want to build a real business, and the grass isn’t always greener.
None of this replaces a good lawyer. Get the artist their own counsel, put everything in writing before the work starts and make sure both sides understand exactly what happens if it ends.
Before The Data tracks artists before the market does.
If you want to find an artist early enough to own a piece of what you build, start with knowing who is moving before anyone else does.
Start the trial →Cover photo: Chappell Roan at the Hollywood Palladium, November 2022, by Justin Higuchi (CC BY 2.0).